Fritzing vs circuits.io vs Eagle – comparing schematics editors

During the recent work on the one dollar variable fan controller, I looked into options for documenting the work.

I have never really used CadSoft Eagle enough to get comfortable with it, and whenever I used it it seemed to be overkill for what I wanted to do. Still, it is usually still seen as the best software for this kind of work.

But maybe there are other options.. In particular I thought the more basic editors sounded promising – let’s give them a try. Disclaimer: Nothing near a full review was made of the different services. The verdicts below are instead based on 15-20 minutes use of each service, and no reading of any manuals or help pages.

Circuits.io

This would be the new kid on the block. Mix schematic editor with GitHub and you get something like Circuits.io. You can follow circuits created by other people, fork your own variants of other people’s circuits etc. Very nice concept, but it also seemed to have a lot of limitations..

circuits.io one dollar fancontroller

Circuits.io used to create a one dollar variable fan controller

For example, I failed mirroring the 7805 in the circuit to the right. Having the output to the left feels very awkward.. I am sure there are ways around it, but even though I really searched for it, I also failed to find a traditional 7805 symbol such as the one in the second image, and was left with the one used in the top schematic. Fail.

Traditional 7805 symbol

Traditional 7805 symbol

There for sure are nice things about circuits.io though. Having an entirely browser based editor is a very nice concept. It might be too early days for it now, but good things come to those who wait… I also liked the feature where you, given a PCB board design, can get files for 3D printing or milling a custom case for your board. Nice!

The fan controller project can be found at http://www.circuits.io/circuits/4841. Go fork it!

Fritzing

This is also a pretty new project, with a lot of promise. It is obviously geared towards hobbyists that might not have a ton of experience in electronics design, but it is still kind of nice.

One dollar variable fan controller, using Fritzing

One dollar variable fan controller, using Fritzing

With a slogan of “from prototype to product” it is clear that the Fritzing team is trying to cover it all. Not sure I would want to go this route with a full project though – I always get suspicious about software that offer a link to some third party service (in this case for manufacturing of PCBs). It probably works perfectly fine – I just feel left without the control I want to have.

Breadboard view in Fritzing
Breadboard view in Fritzing

The schematics editor is nice (better than circuits.io), and I even like the slightly silly feature where you can get a breadboard view of the circuit. Probably not a bit useful for an experienced electronics hacker, but still kind of cute.

The fan controller project can be found at http://fritzing.org/projects/one-dollar-variable-fan-regulator

Eagle

CadSoft Eagle is a professional schematics editor and PCB layout tool. The free version does have some limitations (PCB size and # layers, among others), but they are pretty generous and won’t cause any problems for most hobbyist projects.

The UI feels a bit dated, to be honest. But also quite efficient, given the vast number of components available. Seems lots of people also create their own Eagle libraries with various components, so there is a good chance you can find, download, install and use existing libraries. Otherwise it’s not too hard to create your own, half an hour of fiddling around with libraries left me with a working one. Nice!

Of the three tools Eagle is by far the best, even when considering the somewhat steep learning curve. Give it an hour and you will be able to create fairly complex circuits. PCB layout is still a bit of an art, no matter what product you use – you just have to learn as you go along, and from mistakes. Eagle does have some nice tools for eliminating the most obvious errors though – once again, nice.

All in all, going forward Eagle will (still) be the preferred solution around here.

Advertisements

2 thoughts on “Fritzing vs circuits.io vs Eagle – comparing schematics editors

  1. Lars

    Have you looked at Target3000? Not well known in the US, but popular in Europe. Nice feature like online library search (some in German only….) and 3D preview. Scaling pricing keeps it affordable.

    Reply
    1. gsander Post author

      Sorry, have not looked at it.
      From reading the specs it seems like a nice tool chain, except that it only runs on Windows… Maybe not a show stopper, but doing 90% of my work on OS X, there is always a bit of resistance to boot up the windows machine, realize that you need to apply a bunch of security updates etc etc before starting the actual work.
      Yeah I know – lame excuse, but still 🙂

      Reply

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s